Both UCF and South Florida started true freshman QBs this season. This is the assessment of PFF, which I realize is not a perfect science but it's interesting to see how they rated both players.
Mikey Keene Season Grade - 64.7
Best three games: Tulane (77.1), Memphis (76.1), UConn (74.2)
Worst three games: Cincinnati (41.4), SMU (46.0), usf (62.6)
Timmy McClain Season Grade - 54.8
Best three games: Tulsa (69.2), Houston (69.0), Temple (65.7)
Worst three games: Tulane (30.2), NC State (35.8), FAMU (47.8).
Mikey Keene Season Grade - 64.7
Best three games: Tulane (77.1), Memphis (76.1), UConn (74.2)
Worst three games: Cincinnati (41.4), SMU (46.0), usf (62.6)
Timmy McClain Season Grade - 54.8
Best three games: Tulsa (69.2), Houston (69.0), Temple (65.7)
Worst three games: Tulane (30.2), NC State (35.8), FAMU (47.8).