Ok...so why don't you become a HC and then you can decide who to give or not give a scholarship offer.
Unlike you, Frost actually has followed this QB's progress over the past year or two and even coached him at his past Oregon camp...so again, unlike you, Frost has actually seen him up close and personal...and Frost knows, if someone has tools and is teachable to improve...they could have a chance at future success (zero guarantee of success, just like any other recruit).
NOTE: DYK that Frost's former Heisman Winning QB only had offers from Memphis and then Oregon when he committed...and he still committed to Oregon even though the school already had commitment a higher rated QB, 4 star, Jarred Randall from Hollywood, FL and some kid named Johnny Manziel from TX.
Look now at those 2:
Manziel is on skid row...and Randall ended up signing with LSU...went JUCO route...then to Arizona...and ended his career not playing a down in UA's bowl game. (Finished UA with career stats of 47-98 for 513 yds).