ADVERTISEMENT

OT: Why Bands Matter

I wrestled in high school and admittedly I was in the group of kids who had low opinion of the band geeks . Then I grew up and had kids and my kids wanted to do band. In high school they joined marching band and because I had a truck that could tow our high schools band trailer , I stepped up and towed the trailer to competition and away games. It was then I realized what marching was about and I was a changed person.

Band kids are smart and they are nerds for sure and they arent necessarily athletes. However, they have school spirit ,enjoy performing and as a group they are close knit and support one another. Our high school band director instilled leadership, integrity and discipline in those kids like no other teacher could do. My kids loved it and I appreciated the positive role model and positive culture of marching band.

My son loves being a Marching Knight and during COVID his motivation for college and the stress of it all on him impacted his classroom performance for the worse. The Marching Knights and looking forward to the next season pushed him through some hard times. I have had several good discussions with Dr. Kiser who heads the MKs and I have the utmost respect for him and his leadership style . Once again, I find my son to be amongst leaders that understand the importance of character ,discipline , integrity and community.

Being part of something good I think is what we all crave as people and marching bands from rural communities where I live to urban poor communities is a great experience providing a place for good to happen. Marching band for our family is more than the music, way more than music.
 
To the poster who wondered who cares about marching bands, here’s a real good clue:
A broke marching band parades on Capitol Hill to practice. Magic ensues.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/dc-md-va/2022/10/08/eastern-marching-band-capitol-hill-dc/
No one takes that poster seriously. It’s obvious from his post that he never graduated from UCF or any other university for that matter; and more than likely, he’s never attended one either. He also attempts to put others on the board down at every opportunity but only makes himself look like a total d-bag in the process (just like he made himself look with this response). Anyone who questions the incredible impact university bands contribute to the tradition, pageantry, and atmosphere of a college football program is completely out of touch with the reality of the sport and its meaning. He or she is nothing more than a total embarrassment to himself or herself. Period.
 
When I came here in 99 the band was already better than the other "big 3" and had been for a few years.
Yessir. I graduate HS in 1996 and performing in marching band in college was really important to me as I was considering which university to attend. My HS band director, a UF Alum, told me if I wanted to be part of a very good college marching band program, go to UCF (not UF or FSU, that had what he termed, “romp and stomp bands”). Luckily for me, not only did UCF have a fantastic marching band program in the Marching Knights, they also had an incredibly good nursing program.

That nursing program at UCF was one that would not only guarantee me a phenomenal education as an emergency/trauma nurse, but also prepare me for graduate studies as a nurse practitioner and eventually for doctoral studies when I earned my Ph.D. I am so grateful for the 4 years I spent as a MK and the fact it’s one of the major reasons I chose to move to Orlando and attend our great university (and make my career here).
 
No one takes that poster seriously. It’s obvious from his post that he never graduated from UCF or any other university for that matter; and more than likely, he’s never attended one either. He also attempts to put others on the board down at every opportunity but only makes himself look like a total d-bag in the process (just like he made himself look with this response). Anyone who questions the incredible impact university bands contribute to the tradition, pageantry, and atmosphere of a college football program is completely out of touch with the reality of the sport and its meaning. He or she is nothing more than a total embarrassment to himself or herself. Period.
I would suggest he goes to a game, sits in seats close to the band. Totally unrelated to this thread, but I was watching the rocket launch last night with my kids at the lake in my neighborhood and a bunch of my neighbors were there watching also. Was talking with one and they said they went to the Louisville game, we should of won, blah blah blah. But he had seats right next to the band and we were talking about how cool that is, I remember as a student in the student section you were always right next to the band and by god that’s college football man! Unfortunately the stadium club section is a little too far away to feel that, wish they were a little closer.

Went to Knoxville to the TN UF game for my UF best friend (he always goes to one UCF away game with me) and had to hear their band play Rocky Top 5,000 times it would seem. They REALLY appreciate their band, their walk/march into the stadium from outside coming in over the bridge, down and around to the bottom to stop for a long baton twirl show had like all of the 100,000 people attending the game all around watching and filming. The baton twirler girls were top notch btw, was mesmerizing.
 
My home high school in PA has 250+ in their band. During home games they get together with the student section and rock the house. In a recent interview with an opposing coach he stated directly…. “We have to get out to an early lead. If they score first that band just takes over and gives their team unbelievable momentum.” The players openly admit that the noise of the student section and drum line on kickoffs alone provides unreal excitement.
 
I would suggest he goes to a game, sits in seats close to the band. Totally unrelated to this thread, but I was watching the rocket launch last night with my kids at the lake in my neighborhood and a bunch of my neighbors were there watching also. Was talking with one and they said they went to the Louisville game, we should of won, blah blah blah. But he had seats right next to the band and we were talking about how cool that is, I remember as a student in the student section you were always right next to the band and by god that’s college football man! Unfortunately the stadium club section is a little too far away to feel that, wish they were a little closer.

Went to Knoxville to the TN UF game for my UF best friend (he always goes to one UCF away game with me) and had to hear their band play Rocky Top 5,000 times it would seem. They REALLY appreciate their band, their walk/march into the stadium from outside coming in over the bridge, down and around to the bottom to stop for a long baton twirl show had like all of the 100,000 people attending the game all around watching and filming. The baton twirler girls were top notch btw, was mesmerizing.
That’s awesome! And that alludes to my prior point— Anyone who doesn’t realize that is so incredibly out of touch with college football reality that it renders any of his or her opinions laughably irrelevant.
 
  • Like
Reactions: U C to the F
My home high school in PA has 250+ in their band. During home games they get together with the student section and rock the house. In a recent interview with an opposing coach he stated directly…. “We have to get out to an early lead. If they score first that band just takes over and gives their team unbelievable momentum.” The players openly admit that the noise of the student section and drum line on kickoffs alone provides unreal excitement.
Haha. Love it! 250+ for a HS Marching band is INCREDIBLE!
 
See, I thought this thread was about rock bands and stuff. You know, like Ween. Now that would be awesome to have them come play after the Homecoming Game.
 
Haha. Love it! 250+ for a HS Marching band is INCREDIBLE!
My kid's marching band in highschool was 72 kids which includes the flag corp of about 15 -16 kids. It was a small intimate affair compared to the mega bands of 200-300. Marching Bands and College football are like Bob Seger and Chevy or like chicken wings and rings.
 
  • Like
Reactions: CBlackwellRN
My kid's marching band in highschool was 72 kids which includes the flag corp of about 15 -16 kids. It was a small intimate affair compared to the mega bands of 200-300. Marching Bands and College football are like Bob Seger and Chevy or like chicken wings and rings.
That was about the size of my HS band as well. Now, it’s a lot larger. My high school (Tarpon Springs) has a nationally-recognized and award-winning instrumental music program, thanks to the insanely hard work and dedication of the educator who directs it.
 
Not to mention that extensive research shows music students score significantly higher in standardized tests, including college entry tests (SAT, ACT, etc.) than their peers not in music programs.
 
  • Like
Reactions: CBlackwellRN
Speaking of bands, remember Rice's Marching Owl Band (MOB) ? They just didn't give a shit and to prove it, they got suspended for insulting a former coach during a halftime routine.
 
Haha. Love it! 250+ for a HS Marching band is INCREDIBLE!
Our HS band was that size also, there were a lot of huge bands in the panhandle in the late 70s.

I played in the marching band at Troy State, by the time I got to UCF the Engineering program wore my ass out so just never found the opportunity.
 
  • Like
Reactions: CBlackwellRN
Speaking of bands, remember Rice's Marching Owl Band (MOB) ? They just didn't give a shit and to prove it, they got suspended for insulting a former coach during a halftime routine.
Stanford’s band is by far the worst in college football. I can’t even begin to explain how inexplicably bad it is. I was embarrassed for Stanford when we went to watch UCF play there when its band “performed.” Of course, we embarrassed ourselves pretty bad by getting our a$$es kicked on the field that game too. We got them back though on their return visit to the Bounce House.
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT