ADVERTISEMENT

The boss doesn't want your resume

brahmanknight

Moderator
Moderator
Sep 5, 2007
38,978
12,520
113
Winter Park
BN-LZ014_BLINDH_M_20160105150905.jpg


http://www.wsj.com/articles/the-boss-doesnt-want-your-resume-1452025908

Compose Inc. asks a lot of job applicants. Anyone who wants to be hired at the San Mateo, Calif., cloud-storage firm must write a short story about data, spend a day working on a mock project and complete an assignment.

There is one thing the company doesn’t ask for: a résumé.

Compose is among a handful of companies trying to judge potential hires by their abilities, not their résumés. So-called “blind hiring” redacts information like a person’s name or alma mater, so that hiring managers form opinions based only on that person’s work. In other cases, companies invite job candidates to perform a challenge—writing a software program, say—and bring the top performers in for interviews or, eventually, job offers.

Bosses say blind hiring reveals true talents and results in more diverse hires. And the notion that career success could stem from what you know, and not who you know, is a tantalizing one. But it can be tough to conceal a person’s identity for long.

Kurt Mackey, Compose’s chief executive, realized his managers tended to pick hires based on whom they connected with personally, or those with name-brand employers like Google Inc. on their résumés—factors that had little bearing on job performance, he says.

“We were hiring people who were more fun for us to talk to,” says Mr. Mackey. Trouble was, they were often a poor fit for the job, according to the CEO.
 
That reminds me of the old slogan UCF was using for a while for graduates, "It's who you know." I thought it was stupid and it kinda pissed me off.
 
This might be useful for jobs with fairly narrow scopes of work, but useless for any job that would require someone to manage an array of responsibilities and duties. You also might end up hiring someone that is fine to stick in a dark corner but wouldn't dare showing them to customers or anyone else of importance.
 
The resume is what gets you past the HR screen and to me, after that it's all about seeing if you can hang with me both on subject expertise and personality
 
Resumes are actually going the way of the fax machine. Before it was seen as your introduction and brief expose on your personal work history. NOW, more and more, resumes are seen a "fluff", embellished and there is very little structural consistency making the task of going through them even more difficult. The future of hiring involves questionnaires tailored to the business that the applicant's must answer a certain way in order to be eligible, then they are interviewed for personality once eligibility is established. That's the future. Often they don't go back further than your last 2 jobs and don't care about part-time job you held in college working the coffee stand at the mall...
 
  • Like
Reactions: UCFhonors
Resumes are actually going the way of the fax machine. ..
While this may be true of a couple of very-specific-skill-based industries.....that doesnt make much sense. Resumes are a tool amongst a suite of other valuable HR tools. Saying they will be 'replaced' like a technology advancement anytime soon just isnt true overall. Maybe a long play like 50 years from now when all jobs are by robots anyway....but in the meantime resumes have their value during the process.
 
While this may be true of a couple of very-specific-skill-based industries.....that doesnt make much sense. Resumes are a tool amongst a suite of other valuable HR tools. Saying they will be 'replaced' like a technology advancement anytime soon just isnt true overall. Maybe a long play like 50 years from now when all jobs are by robots anyway....but in the meantime resumes have their value during the process.


According to Adecco and KST staffing, they are abandoning resumes this year as they are being favored less and less, so are other temp and tech-recruiting agencies in favor of a more streamlined approach...
 
According to Adecco and KST staffing, they are abandoning resumes this year as they are being favored less and less, so are other temp and tech-recruiting agencies in favor of a more streamlined approach...

I'm sure it isn't the same thing but I've filled out applications where they added questionnaires and all I can say is that they suck. They take too long and are tedious as hell. If this is all true, I'm not looking forward to applying at company that uses this approach.
 
I'm sure it isn't the same thing but I've filled out applications where they added questionnaires and all I can say is that they suck. They take too long and are tedious as hell. If this is all true, I'm not looking forward to applying at company that uses this approach.


Many places prefer the online submissions. If you drop off a printed resume during the day and don't use their preferred service? They toss it.
 
Many places prefer the online submissions. If you drop off a printed resume during the day and don't use their preferred service? They toss it.

Yeah. I don't remember having submitted a hard copy resume in years for any company to which I've applied (other than the copy you bring to the interview.) It's all electronic anymore.
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT