A big deal for whom, though? When Purdue upset Ohio St, did that position Purdue to be taken more seriously or did people just knock Ohio St? When USF racked up some upsets against P5 opponents, did people find respect for USF or did they downgrade the teams they beat?You quoted my post with something about how regular season upsets were not a big deal and I was moving goalposts. I don't know where you are getting that from. The discussion about college football has long been that the regular season was so great because one loss could be the difference in a national title or not, and that every game was such a big deal. There has never been a time that a major upset in the college football season wasn't considered a big deal.
I'm not saying you're moving the goalposts, I'm saying that CFP and many commentators are. They are trying to say that our bowl wins aren't enough now and we need to take a 2 for 1 with UF to finally get respect. I'm arguing that if they didn't respect us for Bowl wins (and they all forgot about the last Fiesta Bowl), then they will also forget any regular season wins against P5s, especially if those programs are at low points.
We should just build the program, keep winning championships, and take 1 for 1's with the P5s willing to play us instead of losing money and potential fans by jumping through the next hoop that won't actually gain us any respect.