Skidog, I suspect your analogy is correct when it comes to the service academies. However, this a side trail, my brother went to Ga Tech for his BS and MS in mechanical engineering which the Navy paid for. He was ROTC and went onto nuke power school and became a Naval officer and we third in command of the Vaun Steuben sub out of Kings Bay. I suppose his allegiance in football was to Ga Tech and not Annapolis . Though he did teach at the Naval Academy for a few years too. His wife and kids all went to Auburn ,he has his PhD from Auburn and you will never see him wear a Ga Tech shirt. It's all Auburn all the time.
When I started UCF in the fall of 86, then President Trevor Colburn said look to your left and look to your right during his orientation speech. He then said half of you will not graduate. My son has the same GPA I did graduating high school at 3.5 unweighted and a better SAT score than I had and he does not get into UCF. It's where he wants to be. He was wait listed and in the end his 5 letters of recommendation, being part of FRC robotics , marching in band, obtaining Life Scout, all those hours of community service didn't mean jack crap. It came down to a test score. My kid has epilepsy and I can tell you depikote the drug he was on in 9th and 10th grade impacted his memory and such. Prior to becoming epileptic at the age of 13, my son was a straight A kid.
While I agree that Seminole and Valencia may be a back door approach and maybe some look down on it, I can tell you life sometimes gives people a shitty deck of cards. My son got a shitty deck handed to him. In spite of that he has overcome a lot and loves UCF. He may be an outlier . I don't know. What I do know though he will make a good student. He works hard and is bright. He is off that damn drug.
I also know this. A good friend of mine who is an usf bull because they offered chemical engineering and UCF didn't, went to Polk Community College. He is now a vice president of Norboard , makers of OSB. My sister went to Tallahassee CC and then FSU in computer science,she is a big wig at Tripple A in Tampa. I know a lot of successful people who did the state college route and went big schools and do well. The back door thing doesn't mean crap to me. My sister is a die-hard Seminole fan and unfortunately my buddy is a Bulls fan. Going to community college or state college has not diluted their school spirit.