I can promise you that no service people are crushing what degreed people on this board are making. I've got 2 friends who are sadly still bartending, at really good local places, and they're not making anywhere near what me or other degreed people are making.
For ever 1 bartender making gobs of money, there are hundreds who work at shitty bars with bad tippers that make little to nothing.
And yet still ... there are a lot of non-degreed "trades" that are in high demand here in the US, because we're retired a full generation of them without replacement. All out of the argument that professionals that require a college degree are better.
All the more reason why if you get a college degree, it doesn't hurt to have a backup trade ... especially if your degree is in arts. Sadly, because more and more Americans don't grow up with a "trade," these skills are being lost.
I had this very debate with an HR department about 8 years ago, when they shot down my 2nd, desired hire, over him not having a degree. Now understand I wasn't even an employee, but a contractor. But when they started that "well rounded" argument, being that they were business majors, I noted their HP 12 calculator on their desk. That's when I asked their "well rounded" butt to "prove" the "future value" functions in their HP calculator.
Basically my punchline was this ... "It's bad enough you're telling me me who is qualified to work in my department (IT), but keep in mind I actually know more about the theory of the equations you use every day in yours." Working in IT, I've
never seen anything that requires an engineering degree. Now there are some industries where an engineering background helps, but for IT itself, none, nada, zip, in my experience.
Which is why, going the other way, I question anyone with a degree who makes the "well rounded" argument ... especially an arts major. Because learning a trade, even as a backup, easily done in an intern position ... is actually being "well rounded."
If this young lady did, or at least interned a couple of years in college, I'd be more understanding. But if she's like most, she just went to school full-time and partied, and never worked, and wonders why she's a personal assistant getting out.
I know the market is tough ... but this has happened over the years, and people learn trades for a reason.