I don't see a whole lot of difference between a team that wins one game or four games. The fact of the matter is we suck this year. We sucked in 2004, 2006, and 2008. I didn't think we sucked in 2011...we just had QB issues and lost some close games while going through growing pains at that position. I mean if we had beat FIU and Furman by two points and then lost the rest of our games, it wouldn't make a difference to me. We stink. Even if we would have beat FIU and Furman by two points and eeked out wins against Tulane and UConn, it wouldn't make a difference to me. We'd still stink. Your team is either good or bad....we're bad this year.
The good coach, bad coach argument is judgmental and is situational since he has been here for so long, and most other coaches don't last that long. If you don't cherry-pick some coaches from the likes of high-caliber P5 programs I thought you'd be hard-pressed to find anybody that doesn't have several good seasons with a few bad ones thrown in. So I did some research:
According to Wikipedia there are only six current coaches with longer tenures than GOL: Frank Beamer, Bob Stoops, Kirk Ferentz, Gary Patterson, Mark Richt and Gary Pinkel. Even these guys have had some bad seasons.
Beamer really struggled the first six season going 22-40-1 before success kicked in. Then he had a big run of 17 good seasons. The last three full seasons he was 22-17 with a .500 conference record. Many conference titles. So basically he sucked for six years, then was good for seventeen, and now has been very mediocre the last three seasons and is 2-2 so far this season. I could see Beamer hanging it up after this season.
Stoops is at Oklahoma...ridiculous budgets, coaches and recruits. His worst four seasons out of 16 were 7-5, 8-4, 8-5, and 8-5. Many conference titles.
Kirk Ferentz (Iowa) has 16 full seasons so far. He is 121-85 and has gone 70-60 in conference play. He has had six bad/average seasons spread out across his career: 1-10, 3-9, 6-7, 6-6, 7-6, and 4-8. Two conference titles.
Patterson is flat out a great coach. One of the best out there. Even he has had a couple of dud seasons, though. his first year was 6-6, followed by two stellar seasons than back to 5-6. Then they went on a big run of success until entering the Big-12. They struggled the first two years (11-14) while the recruiting was catching up. I'm not going to knock that. It should take 2-3 years to start seeing a difference on the field. Many conference titles. Hmmmm...wonder where TCU would be today if they canned him after that fourth season?!?!?!?
Richt is at Georgia....ridiculous budgets, coaches and recruits. He has only won less than eight games once. Has two conference titles.
Pinkel is at Mizzou. No conference titles in 15 seasons. I would point out he's won five division titles but is 0-5 in conference title games. 117-68 while going 64-54 in conference play. Team struggled to 4-7 and 5-7 in his first two years, then had a decent season, then back to 5-6. Then went 7-5 and 8-5 before going on a little run, then took a step back the first year in the SEC (totally understandable).
Other than Patterson, these are all guys at P5 programs. The only other G5 coaches that have about the same tenure as GOL are Bronco Mendenhall, Frank Solich, Kyle Whittingham (which is now P5) and Rick Stockstill.
Bronco is solid with two conference titles (while in the Mountain West) and consistently winning 8 or more games per year (other than two aberrations). He was 39-9 while part of the powerhouse Mountain West..that's sarcasm. Guy is a solid coach but it's hard to measure success when you aren't in a conference.
Solich has had up-and-down seasons as part of his tenure at Ohio. He is 77-57 overall and 50-32 in conference. No conference titles but has played for the conference title three times. What more can you expect out of Ohio?
Whittingham went 7-5, 8-5, 9-4, 13-0, 10-3, 10-3 while in the Mountain West. He has gone 27-23 in four complete seasons since joining the PAC-12, but only 14-22 in conference play, finishing in 5th three out of four seasons in their division. They are 5-0 this season so far so let's see what happens the rest of the way. He might be saving his job. It might have just taken a liitle longer than thought for the upgraded recruiting to kick in as well. Only time will tell.
Stockstill (Middle Tennessee) is an aberration. He is 59-59 overall and 44-27 in conference play. One conference title his first season then hasn't played for the conference title since. He only has three season out of nine with 8 or more wins. Honestly, I don't know why they've kept him around for this long when he hasn't won anything.
GOL is 81-66 overall and 58-32 in conference with four conference titles. Including this year, will have five bad seasons out of a total of twelve seasons. The highs are very high and the lows are....well low. I don't disagree with those that would like to see us be consistently good every year. I just don't see him getting axed after one bad season, especially after a good run from 2009 to 2014 (55-24 overall and 38-10 in conference, while winning tow conference title, playing for one other and winning a BCS bowl game). It bleeds into next year, yeah, time to seriously consider moving on. Even if we end up with 7-8 wins next year it still may be time to move on based on the college landscape.
For those that make fun of us having CUSA and AAC titles, Utah only has one conference title to it's name as part of the Mountain West. BYU has two Mountain West conference titles (although they have a bunch of years of playing independent).
You guys can make what you want out of this. I just thought it was interesting to see the facts laid out for all these guys/programs. There is a different story and path behind each of these programs.