I get that UCF usf is a rivalry and fans will talk smack, but if we're legit talking about this rationally and logically, can a USF fan really claim that their program has been better/has more accomplishments than ours?
I'd say other than being in the Big East and your head to head record against us, you can't deny that the superior accomplishments favor us. If you took away the UCF name, and someone said in the past 6 seasons, we will give you a BCS bowl win, three (3) 10+ win seasons, 2 top 25 rankings at the end of the season, and 3 conference titles, there is no way you would say "We'll pass."
But if you want to center your argument around our head to head record, that is fine. Also, since you will probably say this, you have had 3 more players drafted than us since 2010 and spent time in the big east. congrats.