In your defense, I mixed the two by responding before you. So ... just to be clear ...
- The OP was complaining, and
- I was the one who introduced using something similar as a "test"
My apologies for any confusion and/or if I took something out-of-context.
But my point on giving people up to $25/head, while saying what they don't spend will go to a charity -- which they will select via nominations and by vote -- is still valid, and not really a "test."
It's not, not at all. In fact, I agree with it. In many surveys over the years, one of the #1 things that can kill your chance in a relationship is how you tip.
And why is that?
It's more important than the place, the setting, the meal ... even the conversation to some (but not all). But universally, women (and a great number of men) see the "tip" as a relationship to how you treat the "worth" of someone else. After all, and maybe it's because I waited tables in my youth, but ...
Tips are the most
direct income you can give someone in virtually
all of capitalism.
It's literally you, the consumer, directly affecting someone's income,
their worth ...
no filters. If you get bad service ... do you leave the standard 15%? Or do you give them "nothing for nothing"? If you get great services, do you push it to 25%? 30%? Even more? Or do you leave the standard 15-20% that "they actually earned"?
It's one of those really "hidden factors" that really factor into a date ... one where it only gives you a "little bonus" if you get right, but can absolutely "veto" the evening at the end, if not.
That's why most rate it as the #1 impact, especially in the case of negative factor.
I.e., I hope you think that I was suggesting it was something about a "big tip" by which you thought "big money" and "rich" as the female consideration? Most women do when I first mention it ... until I explain this is what many studies have shown where guys "go wrong" when the rest of the date went so well. It's how you look at someone's "worth," in a simple, but powerful, moment.
And then most women remember that moment ...
And yes, it fits at least one of their dates, if not several, for most women.
It was the "veto."
BTW ... the "side lesson" for men in one survey was pick a cheaper restaurant than to pick an expensive restaurant, and try to "make it up" by leaving a small tip. That will kill it for a lot of women.