Cristobal is not my first choice. But when I hear people say he can't coach and look at his record I am reminded of the old proverb: It is better to remain silent and let people think you are a fool than to open your mouth and remove all doubt. It has been mentioned that he only won during the one season when he had TY Hilton. Is it possible that he could attract more TY Hilton's to a school like UCF? My guess is that he could. However, that will not solve our problems. UCF is usually going to have solid players at the skill positions. UCF is in Florida and it really isn't that hard to find diamonds in the rough down here, especially at WR, RB, and DB. Where we come up lacking is on the line of scrimmage. We need somebody who can get us solid O-line and D-line recruits and then coach them up. Until we get into a P5 conference, we aren't going to compete for the Martez Ivey's of the world. UCF will have to develop talent like the McCray's and Jordan Rae's of the world.
My choices would be:
Houston Nutt- won pretty big in a state with marginal high school talent
Jim Leavitt- built the USF program from nothing only to watch others destroy it
Mario Cristobal- Good recruiter, would likely be boom or bust.
Matt Campbell- Built a solid program, I guess, I really don't know much about him other than this season
As others have stated, no matter who they hire, there is going to be a risk. I would like to see us hire someone with a proven track record that might see this as their last coaching job and want to stay a while and try to carry us over the P5 threshold. I think if we do get into the P5, we would be a very attractive school to a lot of HC candidates and when this coach decides to retire, you could see some serious interest in this job. What we need in the meantime is to get back to consistently winning. In all honesty, that might take a season or two. If they have found their AD, then he needs to find the next HC in the next 2-3 weeks so they have a decent amount of time to recruit. This recruiting class will be at a disadvantage with the short time spent recruiting. If we hire someone with local ties the learning curve will be far less and it would probably enhance our ability to turn this around quickly, especially if said coach can actually, you know, coach. Leavitt would be able to fall back on his past recruiting relationships in the state of Florida, and I would imagine he would be able to put together a pretty good staff.