Good take. This is the argument I'm trying to make:No. That's just total players. I see where he went, though.
There's a lot to look at. The consensus is there is churn, and programs have to deal with. A lot more churn than is manageable. Hopefully when the NCAA straightens-out kids transferring constantly (they are instituting one immediate transfer, and after that you have to sit s year), and setting up the portal and recruiting to not overlap, schools should have a much better time managing their rosters. Right now it is chaos.
As the OP indicated, "For instance, Lee, O'Keefe, Swoboda, Jackson, Montalvo, Brown, Wilson, JJB, MK, and now Hodges"...well:
1) Lee left for money. Also, we had huge attrition on the OL due to graduation. I guess he figured starting at Miami wouldn't be that different than starting for us, except he is also getting paid...or paid more.
2) O'Keefe left for whatever reason (B.C. Don't really know how this is going to better showcase his talent but his choice; He will get a nice grad degree if he chooses to. I hope he just didn't transfer there for football).
3) Swoboda was a one year guy. He graduated.
4) Jackson graduated.
5) Montalvo graduated.
6) Brown left for money.
7) Wilson graduated.
8) JJB left for whatever reason (Ole Miss).
9) MK left for playing time. Can't really say he is the starter. He was the starter...after the starters got hurt. Obviously is a great backup but he wants to start so he left. I got no problem with that. He's got experience and wants to push himself.
10) Hodges got arrested and kicked off the team.
I don't see anything that strange, considering the conditions of college football right now. What's so abnormal about this in the current atmosphere?
Our starters are just as good as starters at top P5 programs. Lee, JJB, O'Keefe, etc. is evidence of that. The issue is, we do not have the quality back up these schools have.
That's my concern.
Other schools can *plug and play* players better than we can. For example Georgia lost, what 11 players to the draft from last season? But Georgia can plug and play because there is less drop off in production at good schools.
And so losing top starters is a much bigger issue for us than it is for a good P5 school.
Last edited: