ADVERTISEMENT

What are your thoughts on the TRANSFER PORTAL

False report. I thought it was weird a kid from Houston area that played at Zona was coming here. I’d imagine UH would be better for him. Or he didn’t know DG left.
 
Some kids want get paid, so pay them. Some kids want an education, so let them go to school. Give them what they want but make them check a fecking box. The farce of the "student athlete" is has been finally killed off by all this.
 
If all the good kids go to minor leagues, no one will watch college. It will be like baseball. No one really cares.
I understand that is one possible extreme result but that won't happen. Some "Kobe's" will go but it won't kill college ball. If anything it will kill this fantasy that kids are worth $1MM per year.
 
I understand that is one possible extreme result but that won't happen. Some "Kobe's" will go but it won't kill college ball. If anything it will kill this fantasy that kids are worth $1MM per year.
Over estimating why kids come to a school to play football. They come for the coaches, if all the best coaching staffs leave college and go to this other league, all those players will follow. Vast majority of football recruits are not weighing in on which school has the best academics, Alabama or Georgia. Plus no reason a kid can't go to college on the side and play in the other league.
 
If all the good kids go to minor leagues, no one will watch college. It will be like baseball. No one really cares.
It’s more like the other way around for Baseball. Ppl still love watching college baseball and a rare few are in tune with minor leagues.
 
It’s more like the other way around for Baseball. Ppl still love watching college baseball and a rare few are in tune with minor leagues.
How many UCF games do you go to a year? Not many people go. Just look at stands that only hold a few thousand and still empty seats. Our games are rarely on tv. The demand is not there. Will be the same for football. No one will watch the minor league football either. Just like XFL and all the other off leagues.
 
The whole thing is a joke. The NFL needs to pony up and create a developmental league. Let the kids get paid and try their luck there instead of wasting time in the classroom. Let real student athletes play in college.

No they need to get an education not just to get a job or play professional sports but to be well rounded, productive, informed citizens. No country or culture can survive without an educated and informed citizenry. Look at the history of civilization.
 
How many UCF games do you go to a year? Not many people go. Just look at stands that only hold a few thousand and still empty seats. Our games are rarely on tv. The demand is not there. Will be the same for football. No one will watch the minor league football either. Just like XFL and all the other off leagues.
A handful a year at most. They usually have a good crowd, but I’m not just referencing UCF baseball, college baseball as a whole does well at the good baseball schools and always find a game or two on ESPN channels. I’ve been to several different minor league games when I used to travel for work around the SE and they are typically empty and never televised.
 
A handful a year at most. They usually have a good crowd, but I’m not just referencing UCF baseball, college baseball as a whole does well at the good baseball schools and always find a game or two on ESPN channels. I’ve been to several different minor league games when I used to travel for work around the SE and they are typically empty and never televised.
Yes a few schools. Just like women’s basketball. It’s not popular at all for most part. When Bama loses 4 and 5 stars to minor leave they come for our best players and get them. We’d go back to getting CUSA type players. The product won’t be as good and over time will go unnoticed. When I was young MLB was most popular sport in USA. NFL was struggling for fans. It’s flipped.
 
No they need to get an education not just to get a job or play professional sports but to be well rounded, productive, informed citizens. No country or culture can survive without an educated and informed citizenry. Look at the history of civilization.
Its not why most of them go to school. Arguably the college system right now is pretty broken for all. More people are in college to party and starve off the real world than be focused on being educated and building a career. Its more common to talk to someone that graduated with a degree that has nothing to do with their career.
 
Its not why most of them go to school. Arguably the college system right now is pretty broken for all. More people are in college to party and starve off the real world than be focused on being educated and building a career. Its more common to talk to someone that graduated with a degree that has nothing to do with their career.
You are absolutely that it's not why most of them go to school. You are also right that our educational system is certainly damaged if not broken. However, the real purpose of an education is not to to prepare one for a job, though some degrees do that but it is to teach them to think, reason, and problem solve. I believe the world would be far better off with well educated populations, whether they may be digging ditches, playing pro ball or doing brain surgery. We all need to know how to think logically and to reason; how to read, and write and speak, and do everyday math. But most importantly, how to think and reason.
 
Chris Hayes from OS had a decent article today on the Portal and NIL.

"There is no longer any loyalty in college football. Players are only loyal to what a school has done for them lately."
How naive. When has there ever been loyalty? coaches, adminstration, fans, etc are only "loyal" to players who have done something for them.
 
It's an honor for High school athletics to be recruited from division 1 schools. They get a full ride for their education. I have to wonder with so many players still in the transfer portal waiting to be picked up are some of them going to be disappointed and left without a scholarship.
 
It's an honor for High school athletics to be recruited from division 1 schools. They get a full ride for their education. I have to wonder with so many players still in the transfer portal waiting to be picked up are some of them going to be disappointed and left without a scholarship.
Yes. But they probably have FCS offers and are waiting. It was going to happen anyway. Most rosters were around 100 and have to be at 85.
 
Now that we completed the first cycle of the portal. I think it has helped balance the league more. In the past top tier power 5 teams have buried great players in their depth chart. Most players just want to play, they are used to playing coming out of high school. For example; Alabama may have been a dream to go there and play, but the reality is the competition for early playing time can be eye opening.

Looking at this from the G5 side some players that have developed into great players have transfered up to power 5 teams, but this ratio is much smaller.
 
There's not any real legal way to "can" NIL deals.

The whole issue came up because banning kids from earning money was always, at best, a legally grey area, and the public opinion on the issue had turned enough to flip the other way.
 
There's not any real legal way to "can" NIL deals.

The whole issue came up because banning kids from earning money was always, at best, a legally grey area, and the public opinion on the issue had turned enough to flip the other way.
Exactly, I want to see that message. Student athletes can no longer earn money because those choosing to pay them could do with unfair intentions. Or better yet, no one cares that the female volleyball stars can now earn on social media because fans don't care about that sport, but don't allow football/basketball players because I don't want my team to be in a disadvantage. I'm sure those football/basketball players will flock to the schools against NIL.
 
I think the the top P5 conferences (SEC and the BIG10) origionally thought the transfer portal would help them more than weaker conference. One of the biggest advantages they have over lesser conferences is depth. If someone gets hurt or needs a break they just put in a second team or a third team player and there is little to no drop off. Now with the NIL good players don't want to be watching from the bench because they won't make any money from NIL so they will look to transfer to a school where they have a better chance of playing. The top conference may indeed lose depth. Things are going to be very interesting in the coming years.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Yaes
I attempted to use the transfer portal to bring me gold from Ft. Knox....it didn't work. I still believe in the transfer portal, though.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Chargeon2020
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT