http://www.wsj.com/articles/trump-and-bernie-less-is-more-1463611258
If you did a word-association game with people for
Donald Trump and Bernie Sanders, it might go like this:
Donald Trump: wall, trade, terrific.
Bernie Sanders: billionaires, Wall Street, income inequality.
With these words, Donald Trump, the host of “Celebrity Apprentice,” defeated a platoon of professional Republican politicians and is the party’s presumptive nominee.
Bernie Sanders, a Vermont socialist, won’t be the Democrats’ nominee but he has transformed
Hillary Clinton into the incredible shrinking heir apparent.
As a result, some have asked: What is going on with the American electorate? A follow-up question would be: How have Donald Trump and Bernie Sanders gone so far by offering so little?
Everyone gets that these two campaigns are about varieties of anger. But something other than anger is changing America’s politics.
At the Trump campaign
website, five policy positions are listed. Two are “Pay for the Wall” and “Immigration.” Other than trade with China, there is no entry on foreign policy.
Sen. Sanders’s campaign is essentially variations on several evocative phrases. Liberal analysts have debunked what little detail he has proposed as implausible, notably on health care.
And still: political minimalism is a winner in 2016.
The Trump and Sanders phenomena really have more in common with
Facebook communities than with the two political parties. Maybe that’s the future. Criticizing them, we’ve all learned, violates the social bond.
There have to be professional Democrats who wish they could roll Bernie’s new magic voter dice against Donald Trump’s this fall.
Of course we can’t govern this way. The Trump and Sanders electorates are right in their anger about poor wage growth, but it’s still going to be a mistake if the next president, elevated out of a culture of sentiment, is incapable of policy execution.
This is a presidential campaign for our time. What comes after, the world and its many realities, will still be old school.