Definitions based on being a G5 program and our results since becoming a football program in 2004, instead of just having a football team. Opinions will differ but this is what I roll with.
12 or more wins = Elite (You won your conference title and played in a major bowl). Example = 2013, 2017, 2018
10-11 wins = Very Good (You probably won your conference title but are not in a major bowl). Example = 2007, 2010, 2012, 2019
8-9 wins = Good (You beat who you should beat at home, and probably were => .500 in road games. Play in some schlub bowl. Doubtful you played for conference title. A bad year for your program should be “good”). Example = 2005, 2009, 2014, 2021
7 wins or less = You’ve got problems. You still might have played in some schlub bowl. Example = 2004, 2006, 2008, 2011, 2015, 2016, 2020(***6-4 Covid season. Only played 9 regular season games. Probably would have ended up “good”***)
So in 18 seasons this breaks out as:
3 Elite
4 Very Good
4 Good
7 You’ve got problems
I’ll have to slightly modify some of these definitions in the future, as being in a major conference means you have better bowl tie-ins and a greater margin of error to get in bowls.
I’d love to see this applied to all teams that have been playing FBS football since 2004 to see what percentile we’d fall in as a program. In fact, I’ve given myself this assignment and when I complete it I’ll let you know what it shows.