I am watching the games . not sure what you are watching. QB is about leadership as well and how the team responds to them. You seem like you just don’t want to admit that you could be wrong .
"Joe Montana made a hall of fame career out of short throws mixed in with the occasional long ball".
The question is who do you want to be your starter and who gives you the best chance of winning? Nothing wrong with having your own opinion and it doesn't even have to make sense. Just don't expect everyone else to agree with your logic.
We were taking about MK, so you were making a comparison between him and Joe Montana, not the play calling. Be more specific next time to make your point.
Joe Montana made a hall of fame career out of short throws mixed in with the occasional long ball.
You have been the biggest MK hater on this board for a while. You are entitled to that opinion but don’t say you’re not hating on MK.
Man I agree completely. Every game I come away with what seems to me so many questionable offensive calls and a defense that plays so far off receivers that it baffels me. So many times the receiver already has, or is, very near the 1st down marker without a defensive player in sight. Just too many times receivers are uncovered.
If our secondary can't tighten up their coverage it's going to get ugly fast. They never seem to improve from their mistakes.
I have more confidence in MK keeping drives alive on 3rd down, which is a higher percentage passing down.. Any of our stat masters have the 3rd down efficiency for both QBs?
We like MK because the ball moves when he is at QB. With JRP, the offense is clunky, feels like we are always on 3rd down and praying to convert.
maybe the play of the game. Could have had two guys ejected if he hadn’t thrown them down.
Felt good beating those a-holes after celebrating their targetting penalty
I couldn't believe the announcers were trying to just explain it away like it wasn't a big deal. complete nasty hit and then he runs and does it again on the same play. The guy was clearly accelerating and targeting with the Crown of his helmet.
that rubbed me the wrong way ..they were laughing on the sideline
He was acting shocked he got flagged for it. Literally led with the crown teice on same play
If our guys did that I would also be upset. Very unsportsman like. My view on Memphis has really changed for the worse after that.
You compared MK to Joe Montana, one would question if you were drunk when you said this. I agree Joe Montana was a hall of famer playing in a West Coast Offense, nothing like Gus’ offense. What other point are you trying to make?
How was I hating on MK in what you responded to? Last year he wasn’t good, I’m well documented on that stance as you noted. The past 2 games I said he played great. All I said was JRP brings a better dynamic to the offense and stated the offensive stats, stated Memphis being one of the worst defenses we have played and having results worse than our average offensive stats during this game winning by 1 score. Thus, I feel JRP would have done better, yet many who have been pining for MK and “hating” on JRP have used this to justify he is the guy. I’m just saying I think JRP would have done better, looking at the whole picture vs the 98th ranked defense (worst defense we have played to date FBS) and having less yards and less points than our average.
Statistically worse or significantly worse? I’m trying to understand what you are quantifying that statement as…your feeling or actual? Completion percent, sure as Gus won’t call many plays with MK in longer than 10 yards, obviously the completion percentage would be better.
