I think the reality is this:
1. When we hired Frost we knew he was bringing in a new system which would make the current crop of QBs obsolete. We hoped that one of them could step in and run it effectively but none could. Our two top pro-style QBs transferred. Holman was the only real choice to start. .
2. When Holman went down our options were Patti and Milton. Milton was better than Patti.
3. Knowing that we would have a QB problem next year Frost refused to bow down to pressure to put Holman/Patti in so that Milton could get real game day experience. Win or lose.
4. Milton was not ready physically, mechanically or mentally to be the starter, but was thrown into a very tough situation. Had 6 weeks of college training before getting thrown to the dogs.
5. When you are the starter you and you are having to get around the learning curve of the offense, have not had the benefit of strength and conditioning or spring training, each week you are having to prepare for a new opponent and scheme that you have never seen before, are playing on a D1 level for the first time, on a team that went 0-12 the year before, with the pressure of the entire team and fans on your shoulders along with taking college courses as a freshman you don't have much time to work on mechanics. You are pretty busy just surviving and getting by.
6. Despite this and the fact that we had problems with a new offense and O-line Milton won some games and showed sparks of great talent. He also made mistakes that you would expect a QB in this situation to make.
7. Frost and company recruited 3 QB prospects, one of which decided to de-commit weeks before signing day. My guess is that 1)there were no other options that were worth a scholarship or 2) Bringing in another QB might have spooked that recruits that we had who see the opportunities for early playing time.
8. Milton will now have a summer to work on mechanics, strength and conditioning. A spring to work on form, reads and the playbook. He will bulk a little and mature a great deal.
9. Our only options for QBs are Milton, Divino and 2 incoming true freshman. I think Frost knows this and was either willing to risk it or to use this coming season as a learning year.
10. Some of our fans have outrageous expectations and instead of being excited for the promise the team showed this season (including Milton) are spoiled by the fact that we won enough games to go to a bowl game.
Expect that next year this team may regress because I think they over performed last season. We still have a lot of growing up and learning to do. Get behind Milton because he is likely to be our guy for good or bad. This off season will make or break his college career. I for one hope that neither the the new freshman QBs see action at all next season