At this point if we hire Frost it's a bigger indictment of Terry than anything. He's been available the whole time and Terry also knew Gus was leaving but it took a week to hire a guy who was immediately available? I appreciate what Frost was able to do in 2017 and I think there are ways for him to return but we don't owe him the job based on one magical year.
I agree - I think we continue to take a chance with an up and coming coach over a coach that left us for supposedly greener pastures. As far as I'm concerned, he's been out of the coaching game for a bit. Will he be able to coach in the new NIL environment? We saw that Gus struggled with that here. What about the player cap? We are about to see walk on positions go away and a hard cap on players. We aren't in the AAC any more, will he be able to handle a team in the Big12? When he was here the first time, there was not nearly as much pressure to win, since he left, the fanbase expects to see 8, 9, or 10+ win seasons. The rumors that he couldn't handle it up in Nebraska were that he turned to the bottle and drank heavily. Not that I believe the coach can't have a drink or two, but I don't want him getting shit faced when he also needs to be out recruiting after games/Fridays. Coaches need to be able to handle a loss and still be able to get out there and recruit. When he was here the first time, he could get gas or walk into the Wawa and get a coffee and nobody would recognize him. Now he would be the face of UCF again. People would recognize him. He would have that celebrity status here.
There would be pros and cons to hiring Frost. Pro - we like the type of offense he runs, its exciting. It's the type of offense the UCF fans enjoy. Heupel built around it because that was what Frost left him. That type of offense put UCF on the map. We saw that Frost has the ability to coach players up. We saw it with KZ after year 1, but that was all we had to go on while he was at UCF. Frost has a good eye for QB talent - Martinez, Thompson, Chubba, Smothers, Haarberg, and Torres all had talent and put up decent stats. When he was here, he gave up some of his salary to pay his coaching staff. Cons - Frost needs to find a coaching staff and it sounds like he burned a lot of bridges at Nebraska. Who would be working with him? Are they good? Does he have a great potential DC in his back pocket?
With an up and coming coach, we run the risk that they will bail for the Big10/SEC. If we were able to snag a good up and comer, if we were able to give them some great performance metrics like they did with Heupel, then its foreseeable they would stay longer. Heupel had incentives around selling tickets, actual attendance at games, viewership, total wins, wins against ranked opponents, weekly rankings/EOY ranking, Game Day/Big Noon Kickoff games, etc. We need to reward the entire coaching staff so they stay. Consistency is what brings out the best in players. If we are constantly changing the playbook every year, you won't see continued progress which is why I believe Gus failed. We started with DG/MK who were not dual threat QBs and Gus wanted them to change to his system and they left as a result. Gus got his own guy and had some success. This year our QB room flopped overall. Its tough when you're 4th string happened to be the best on the bench. You have to ask yourself, why did the coaches not see it? I was OK with Gus staying until the Utah game when I saw Rizk going back to the side line and Gus making a face and walking away. That pissed me off as much as Heupel's team fighting on the side line at Tulsa. Gus did not prepare the team at all to play that Utah game. Everyone looked like they skipped practice and film time to play video games for the week.